How Businesses Can Face Litigation Over Biometric Data and Online Tracking

AdobeStock_2125193040-300x200

Whether in Silicon Valley or beyond, businesses increasingly use biometric identification systems, website analytics, and online tracking technologies to improve office security, evaluate customer behavior, and streamline business operations. These technologies can create litigation exposure when companies collect, use, or disclose personal information without complying with applicable California privacy laws.

California companies may face claims involving facial recognition, employee fingerprint systems, website tracking pixels, and the unauthorized disclosure of customer information. This article examines where those claims can arise and what measures businesses can take to manage these risks.

What is Biometric Information?

Biometric information includes physical or behavioral characteristics that technology can use to identify individuals. Businesses may collect this information through fingerprint scanners, facial recognition systems, voice authentication software, and other identification technologies. Common biometric uses in the workplace include using these systems for employee timekeeping, access control, fraud prevention, or customer authentication.

California regulates certain uses of biometric information through the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), as amended by the California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA). The CCPA includes biometric information as a category of personal information and treats it as sensitive personal information when it is processed to uniquely identify a consumer. Covered businesses may face regulatory enforcement for failing to comply with applicable requirements. Their handling of biometric information can also lead to contractual disputes or litigation under other legal theories. Potential issues include inadequate privacy disclosures, unauthorized collection or sharing, insufficient data security, and retention practices that conflict with legal obligations or company policies.

Online Tracking Technologies Create Additional Litigation Risks

Whether in Silicon Valley or beyond, many businesses use website analytics, advertising pixels, cookies, and session-replay software to understand how visitors interact with their websites. These tools can collect information about browsing activity, device identifiers, page visits, and user interactions.

Companies commonly deploy these technologies for marketing and operational purposes. Their use can create legal exposure when tracking goes beyond what users consented to or what applicable law permits. California businesses have faced lawsuits under the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) alleging that website tracking tools intercepted electronic communications without consent.

For example, a plaintiff may allege that a tracking tool allowed a third-party vendor to capture the contents of a communication while it was being transmitted. Whether the claim succeeds depends on how the technology operates, what information it captures, the vendor’s role, and whether legally sufficient consent was obtained. The timing and scope of consent can matter as much as the wording of the privacy policy.

2027 Update: How California Senate Bill 690 Affects Online Tracking Litigation

California recently enacted Senate Bill 690 (SB 690), which takes effect January 1, 2027. The bill amends Penal Code section 637.2, the civil remedies provision of the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA). Under the amendment, only the California Attorney General may bring an action under section 637.2 against a private actor for an alleged violation of section 638.51 arising from conduct on a website, online application, or mobile application. Section 638.51 governs pen registers and trap-and-trace devices. The limitation also applies retroactively to pending claims in actions commenced within the two years before the bill takes effect.

Businesses may still face private lawsuits under other CIPA provisions, including section 631(a), which addresses unauthorized interception of communications. Companies should continue reviewing their online tracking technologies, consent procedures, and privacy disclosures to identify potential compliance issues and reduce litigation exposure.

Healthcare Companies Face Additional HIPAA Compliance Risks

Healthcare providers, medical technology companies, and other businesses that collect or process patient information face additional legal obligations under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). The federal law establishes privacy and security requirements for protected health information (PHI) maintained or transmitted by covered entities and their business associates.

California healthcare companies should pay particular attention to biometric identification systems, patient portals, appointment scheduling platforms, and website tracking technologies. Depending on how these systems operate, they may collect or disclose information protected under HIPAA. For example, tracking pixels or analytics software integrated into patient portals could transmit sensitive health information to third-party vendors without appropriate authorization or another lawful basis.

Common Sources of Biometric Privacy and Online Tracking Claims

  1. Inadequate disclosures and consent procedures. Companies may face claims when they fail to explain how they collect biometric information or deploy online tracking technologies. Certain activities may trigger specific notice, consent, or opt-out requirements.
  2. Third-party technology providers. Businesses frequently rely on outside vendors for analytics, advertising, identity verification, and data storage. Vendor agreements should address data collection, permitted uses, confidentiality, security obligations, and responsibility for compliance.
  3. Excessive data collection or retention. Collecting more information than necessary or retaining it longer than reasonably necessary for the applicable purposes can increase exposure. Companies should establish retention and deletion procedures appropriate to the information and governing law.
  4. Inconsistent privacy practices. A company’s actual data collection activities may differ from its published privacy policy. These inconsistencies can become significant evidence in regulatory investigations and private litigation.
  5. Inadequate security controls. Unauthorized access to sensitive information can lead to investigations, contractual claims, and, under qualifying circumstances, private actions under California privacy law.

How California Businesses Can Reduce Litigation Exposure

Companies should evaluate privacy compliance as part of their broader corporate risk management practices rather than treating it solely as an information technology issue. A useful starting point is an inventory of biometric systems, website tracking tools, and third-party services that collect or process personal information. Management should understand what information each system collects, why the company needs it, where it goes, and how long the business retains it.

Companies should also review their privacy notices, consent mechanisms, vendor contracts, and internal data protection policies. Legal and technical teams can work together to determine whether the company’s practices align with applicable statutory requirements.

When litigation is reasonably anticipated, companies should promptly preserve relevant records, including vendor agreements, website configurations, consent records, and communications about data collection. Early legal analysis can help management assess potential liability, evaluate defenses, and respond to threatened or pending claims.

Consult a California Business Litigation Attorney

To discuss a potential dispute involving biometric information, online tracking, or other business litigation matters, contact Structure Law Group, LLP to schedule a consultation with a California business litigation attorney. Our California attorneys represent startups and established businesses in Silicon Valley and throughout California in a broad range of commercial disputes and work with business owners and executives to evaluate litigation risks, respond to claims, and develop strategies for resolving disputes and protecting their companies’ legal and financial interests.

Contact Information